The Biden administration is planning to propose a ban on menthol cigarettes, a long-sought public health goal of civil rights and anti-tobacco groups that has been beaten back by . Your email address will not be published. Once menthol is banned, store shelves would only offer unflavored cigarettes. Phillip Gardiner, a co-founder of the African American Tobacco Control Leadership Council, summarized the history of these techniques. Though menthol products make up about 30 percent of sales to white smokers, they compose, 85 percent of the market among Black smokers. Menthol and lipstick-style cigarettes will be taken off the shelves as tobacco will have to be sold in plain packaging. Product categories. [52], Menthol cigarettes have been shown to inhibit nicotine metabolization, leading to increased systemic nicotine exposure and increased nicotine addiction. We do know that the number of smokers is rapidly declining, however, the risks and negative health effects associated with smoking still exist. moderates how we perceive pain, which ultimately gives menthol the ability to dampen irritation or discomfort. This blog discusses the potential impacts of this ban. Algarve Tourism Algarve Hotels Algarve Bed and Breakfast Algarve Vacation Rentals These proposed rules are in response to public health concerns about the dangers of menthol cigarettes and their huge popularity among young . In the UK, a pre rolled pack of 20 'Menthol cigarettes' with a filter attached are banned. Fallout 4: Welcome To The Commonwealth! (Credit: Danijela Maksimovic/Shutterstock), Sign up for our email newsletter for the latest science news, Want More? Offers may be subject to change without notice. And Canada's experience with a similar ban suggests that it is unlikely an illegal market would emerge. Cigarette smoking has been on the decline for years. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. That way, when the bans take effect and someone with any inclination to quit sees that their favorite product is no longer available, the resources they need to stop are as accessible as the non-menthol cigarettes in stores. Read on to learn more about the FDAs suggested menthol ban and when it might take effect. No matter how exactly menthol improves unpleasant smoking experiences, its a benefit that new users latch onto. Get CNN . In December 2010, workers from the Bakery, Confectionery, Tobacco Workers and Grain Millers' International Union protested outside a meeting between FDA officials and industry representatives in Raleigh, North Carolina, arguing that a menthol ban would cost many workers their jobs. The reasoning behind the decision is because menthol cigarettes cause 87.5% of the smoking-related deaths. [5], Menthol cigarettes are constructed similarly to non-mentholated cigarettes, with menthol added at any of several stages during the manufacturing process. And the flavor makes the cigarettes "easier" to use. A menthol cigarette is a cigarette flavoured by menthol - a minty flavoured chemical compound found naturally in peppermint. Kathy Hochul proposes in her executive budget that the tax on a pack of cigarettes rise by $1 from its current $4.35. "It's then that the industry began to pivot aggressively towards targeted marketing in Black communities," said Wailoo. Seeing that tobacco serves as a leading cause of death from cancer, according to the FDA, the agency is looking to rid the U.S. of the ingredient that makes smoking more tolerable and easier to become addicted to. [52][53], Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration, Family Smoking Prevention and Tobacco Control Act, Tobacco Products Scientific Advisory Committee, African American Tobacco Control Leadership Council, National Organization of Black Law Enforcement Executives, Bakery, Confectionery, Tobacco Workers and Grain Millers' International Union, National Association of Convenience Stores, Tobacco marketing targeting African Americans, "Smoking Quit Rates Among Menthol vs Nonmenthol Smokers: Implications Regarding a US Ban on the Sale of Menthol Cigarettes", "Are Menthol Cigarettes Riskier Than Non-Menthol? But there is a way you can get your hands on your favourite cigarettes after the ban comes in. One of the major changes in the tobacco market is the reassessment of smoking bans. [4] Less heavily mentholated than Kool, Salem was positioned as an all-purpose cigarette, and captured 0.8% market share within their first year. The more smoke inhaled, the more nicotine inhaled; nicotine was found at higher concentrations in the blood of mice that took in menthol over unflavored puffs. And when his lab exposed rodents which had never breathed in smoke before to smoke that was laden with menthol, their breathing remained closer to normal rates. [17] It has been proposed that menthol cigarettes, which are more addictive but no less harmful,[13][18] should be banned, partially on grounds that race-specific marketing for a more addictive product is a social injustice. Jordt has watched the effect play out in mice. Due to the ban on Menthol cigarettes in California in 2023, many people will be looking for ways to buy Menthol cigs. The ban wouldn't affect menthol e-cigarettes but it could impact the sale of other products, such as heated-tobacco devices or cigarettes with very low nicotine levels. In the U.S., 81% of Black smokers and 51% of Hispanic smokers used menthols . They are no less harmful to smoke than normal cigarettes and do not have a lower risk of lung cancer and other smoking-related diseases. Although the use of menthol in ointments and cough drops is regulated by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) in the United States of America, regulation of cigarettes was removed from their purview in 2000 by the Supreme Court in a 54 ruling, FDA v. Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp.[33] The FDA, under the 2009 Family Smoking Prevention and Tobacco Control Act, banned characterizing flavors in cigarettes; however, mentholated tobacco products were exempt. We also use content and scripts from third parties that may use tracking technologies. react to respiratory irritants by recording breathing rates. We use your sign-up to provide content in the ways you've consented to and improve our understanding of you. The ban will ".. give birth to yet another very profitable illicit market." Updated 17:00, 9 MAR 2017. Beginning on May 4, 2022, the FDA will open itself up to accept comments from the public on the proposed rules it hopes to implement. According to a 2018 National Survey on Drug Use and Health, 85% of Black smokers preferred menthol cigarettes. If tobacco companies incorporate similar molecules into cigarettes, manufacturers might be able to argue they are complying with flavoring regulations while still providing an additive that similarly makes inhaling less challenging. [22], In addition to high use by African Americans, menthol cigarettes are used disproportionately by adolescents, women, and lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender (LGBT) Americans. In the U.S., it is estimated that there are nearly 18.6 million current smokers of menthol cigarettes. Once menthol is banned, store shelves would only offer unflavored cigarettes. In surveys, Rose and her colleagues, heard from young smokers that menthol cigarettes are easier to smoke. No handing out free loose cigarettes to people under 21. The FDA published a proposal to ban the sale of menthol cigarettes as well as all flavored cigars and tobacco products. If you are a resident of another country or region, please select the appropriate version of Tripadvisor for your country or region in the drop-down menu. The proportion of smokers who use menthols rose from 31% in 2004 to 33.7% in 2010, according to a 2010 study by the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration. On March 18, 2011, the Tobacco Products Scientific Advisory Committee (an advisory panel to the FDA) concluded that removing menthol cigarettes from the market would benefit public health in the United States, but stopped short of recommending that the Food and Drug Administration take any specific actions, like restricting or banning the additive. Cross border smuggling will fill the gap of the prohibition.". With the introduction of current laws, there is a growing concern for the future of cigarettes themselves. Typically, researchers. However, according to the FDA, State and local law enforcement agencies do not independently enforce the Federal Food, Drug and Cosmetic Act and do not, and cannot, take enforcement actions against any violation of FDAs tobacco authorities, including its regulations, on the FDAs behalf.. [8], In the United States, menthols comprise about 30% of the total cigarette market. Harvard T.H. D.C. later issued a similar ban. hide caption. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. 22 This ban was an important first . This blog will give you an idea of what this might look like in the future. "If finalized, this rule will make the manufacturing and sale of menthol cigarettes illegal in the United States. I was obviously very thrilled to see the FDA stepping up and announcing that they were going to put this policy into place, says Shyanika Rose, a commercial tobacco control and health equity researcher at the University of Kentucky College of Medicine. Teenager woke to find bedroom on fire after e-cigarette charger exploded, Dad reveals shocking scars after lifetime of smoking left him with cancer in his tonsils, Vile dad texted 'SHUT UP' to screaming daughter on night she died alone and covered in maggots - as sick parents jailed for killing disabled teen daughter by letting her balloon to 23st, Seven bombshell claims from Matt Hancock's leaked WhatsApps during pandemic, Harry and Andrew learning they won't 'get what they want' under King Charles, says expert, Dawn French brings back her signature bob as she shows off her impressive weight loss, Worlds most scenic city is in the UK - and it's beaten the likes of Paris and Sydney, 'FINAL AND CRUEL PUNISHMENT': Harry and Meghan 'stunned' and two other royals 'appalled' by Frogmore eviction, says pal, Ed Sheeran reveals wife Cherry had 'inoperable' tumour during pregnancy, Amy Nuttall 'rumbled' husband Andrew Buchan's 'affair' over detail in new lingerie, Dad-of-three tragically drowns in hot tub on weekend break to seaside with family, Attacker tries to smash into house as cops 'blame football' for delay in 999 response, Love Island's Olivia accuses Jessie of 'coming at her' as she's slammed over 'fake' claims, King Charles evicted Harry and Meghan 'just 24 hours after Spare was released', Subscribe to Daily Mirror and Sunday Mirror newspapers. The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) proposed new rules today to prohibit these products and flavored cigars. Well, it doesnt mean anything quite yet, other than the idea to ban flavored tobacco has been introduced, and efforts are underway. Or by navigating to the user icon in the top right. In research with people trying to break cigarette addictions, those using menthol cigarettes tend to have a harder time too. Menthol basically activates this cold receptor, and that's why we feel cooling when we are exposed to menthol, when we inhale it or when we put it on our skin, Jordt says. Lower-tar menthol cigarettes may have menthol levels up to 2%, in order to keep menthol delivery constant despite the filtration and ventilation designs used to reduce tar. [1][2] Some countries still allow menthol and capsule filter tips that are sold separately. The ban also wouldnt be the first of its kind in the U.S. Bigger pauses between breaths indicate that bothered mice lungs. Menthol cigarettes sit on a table in Los Angeles on April 28, 2022. These are less popular among Black smokers, who might also be more susceptible to tobacco carcinogens compared to white smokers. "It's a long time coming," said Keith Wailoo, author of the book Pushing Cool: Big Tobacco, Racial Marketing, and the Untold Story of the Menthol Cigarette. While it could take the FDA years before it is able to enforce a ban on menthol-flavored cigarettes and cigars, it is actively working to get the ball rolling. The FDA says that in 2019, there were more than 18.5 million menthol cigarette smokers ages 12 and older in the U.S., Sadly, the rate of cigarette use is increasingly higher for youth, young adults, and African Americans and other racial and ethnic groups., As a way to potentially reduce these numbers, the FDA has proposed to ban menthol, a move many health experts have backed for years. After all of the comments have been reviewed and considered, the FDA will issue a final determination. The agency has been clear that it cannot and will not enforce the ban on individual consumers of menthol cigarettes or flavored cigars. While it could take the FDA years before it is able to enforce a ban on menthol-flavored cigarettes and cigars, it is actively working to get the ball rolling. [28] But several provinces had already banned it before at the provincial level, for example Quebec, Alberta, Nova Scotia, Ontario and New Brunswick. [42][43][44], Groups representing law enforcement officers also oppose the ban. All of the unique hazards of menthol cigarettes their relatively easy adoption, the possibility that they speed up addictions and make quitting harder are more likely to impact Black smokers. Advocates of menthol cigarette bans think that eliminating the flavoring will reduce the number of new smokers and push current smokers to quit, particularly among those disproportionately impacted by these cigarettes, like Black smokers. TikTok star, 28, is charged with child abuse after 'attack on boyfriend', Rape survivor slams Gabby Petito Utah cop over handling of her case, 'Dark details' about boyfriend of US swim champ who mysteriously died, Disturbing red flags of Lindsay Clancy's psychosis before she 'killed 3 kids', 2020 THE SUN, US, INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED | TERMS OF USE | PRIVACY | YOUR AD CHOICES | SITEMAP, Plans to ban menthol cigarettes in the US started over two decades ago. Nous, Yahoo, faisons partie de la famille de marques Yahoo. Keep up to date on Pocono news, art, and events by following us on the Newsbreak app. But menthol cigarettes are one segment of the tobacco market that has remained strong. In a disclosure, the FDA states, Importantly, the FDA cannot and will not enforce against individual consumers for possession or use of menthol cigarettes or flavored cigars. In other words, the FDA will target manufacturers, distributors, wholesalers, importers, and retailers who manufacture, distribute, or sell such products within the US, not smokers themselves. [50][51], Young people who use menthol cigarettes are also thought to be 80% more likely to become life-long smokers than those who use regular cigarettes. Informations sur votre appareil et sur votre connexion Internet, y compris votre adresseIP, Navigation et recherche lors de lutilisation des sites Web et applications Yahoo. The FDA states, menthol is a flavor additive with a minty taste and aroma that reduces the irritation and harshness of smoking. Activists are pushing back on efforts by Gov. Proposed Menthol Ban Could Leave 22nd Century's VLN Menthol King as the Only Menthol Cigarette in the $26 Billion U.S. Menthol Market FDA to Advance Reduced Nicotine Content Standards for All . [19], Despite it being illegal at the time, tobacco marketers gave out free menthol cigarette samples to children in black neighborhoods in the U.S.[20][21] Similar practices continue in Sub-Saharan Africa, where a 2016 study found over 12% of South African students had been given free cigarettes by tobacco company representatives. Euromonitor International is the leading provider of strategic market research reports. The gene in question influences sensory neurons, and the variation might influence someones preference for menthol cigarettes, the authors think. This blog will examine the pros and cons of this new legislation. When combined with tobacco, the cooling, tasty menthol makes it easier to inhale irritating smoke. If finalized, the newly proposed menthol product standard will: So what does this mean for the millions of adult smokers who enjoy menthol cigarettes? Menthol cigarettes are to be banned under a new EU ruling on the sale of tobacco. Rose would also like to see smoking cessation programs become more widely available. Jordt cant say for certain what biological processes were controlling how mice reacted to the smoke, though the receptors that. The FDA had banned flavored cigarettes from being manufactured or sold in 2009. "Transitioning from a regulated market to an illicit one will lead to about $30 billion of an illicit market," said Major Neill Franklin, former Executive Director of the Law Enforcement Action Partnership (LEAP). But menthol was exempted from that flavor ban because of the success of the tobacco industry in winning supporters among Black elected officials who argued successfully that menthol was a flavor preference among African Americans. From the 13th July, 2023, all cigarettes that are in the market today, including menthol cigarettes will be banned in California. Menthol cigarettes feel less harsh to smoke than regular cigarettes which is why they are often smoked by young people. Despite this significant effect, both Jordt and Rose think that bans alone aren't enough. First developed in 1924 1, menthol cigarettes have long been a feature of the cigarette market. The agency will also host listening sessions on June 13 and 15, 2022. In turn, the receptor partially. The Gangs All Here! In March 2012, Brazil became the first country to outlaw flavored cigarettes, including menthol cigarettes,[29] but was unable to enact it due to the tobacco industry interference resulting in a lengthy court battle. Just over a year ago I wrote about the Biden Administration's plan to ban menthol. New rules govern that changes must be made in the tobacco industry to deter people from smoking . https://public-inspection.federalregister.gov/2022-09302.pdf, Sea Creature Feature of the Week: Harp Seal, PennDOT: Monroe County Road Work This Week 11-7, Dont Miss Out | Taurid Meteor Shower This Weekend, Reduce the appeal of cigarettes, particularly to youth and young adults, decreasing the likelihood that nonusers who would otherwise experiment with menthol cigarettes would progress to regular smoking; and. One of the most important issues facing tobacco companies and their customers is what will happen to the sale of menthol cigarettes come 2023. According to the FDA, studies indicate a ban on menthol cigarettes would save up to 654,000 lives within 40 years, including the 238,000 members of the Black community. There has been a complete ban on menthol cigarettes in Canada since October 2021. I was obviously very thrilled to see the FDA stepping up and announcing that they were going to put this policy into place, says Shyanika Rose, a commercial tobacco control and health equity researcher at the University of Kentucky College of Medicine. En cliquant sur Refuser tout, vous refusez tous les cookies non essentiels et technologies similaires, mais Yahoo continuera utiliser les cookies essentiels et des technologies similaires. This blog discusses the potential impacts of this ban. The ban is estimated to push 1.3 million smokers to quit smoking, according to a recent study. Hochul's planned ban on menthol cigarettes and other flavored tobacco while raising the tax on smokes by $1 claiming it'll fuel the . Jordt points out that other industries have developed chemicals similar to menthol that lack the taste but still deliver a cooling sensation and have cropped up in e-cigarettes. Studies suggest that by imposing such a ban, the U.S. could see a 15 percent reduction in smoking within 40 years.. Some of the predicted results of the U.S. ban played out in Canada when the federal government prohibited menthol sales in October of 2017. But use of menthol cigarettes among smokers is not uniform: Nearly 85% of all non-Hispanic . More than 85 percent of Black people who smoke opt for menthols, and one study found that 44.5 percent of Black people who smoke menthols would try to quit if the flavor additive were banned . Tobacco will have to be sold in 2009 and 15, 2022 will banned! Will also host listening sessions on June 13 and 15, 2022 June 13 and 15, 2022 time.. Nicotine metabolization, leading to increased systemic nicotine exposure and increased nicotine addiction menthol cigarettes in Canada when the government. To buy menthol cigs with people trying to break cigarette addictions, those using menthol cigarettes to! The Food and Drug Administration ( FDA ) proposed new rules today to prohibit these products services. Market research reports blog will give you an idea of what this might look like in the ways you consented. Additive with a similar ban suggests that it is unlikely an illegal market emerge... Fda States, menthol cigarettes are one segment of the prohibition. `` reacted to the,. Began to pivot aggressively towards targeted marketing in Black communities, '' said Wailoo Los Angeles April! Ways you 've consented to and improve our understanding of you as well as all flavored cigars, 2022 smoking. Fda will issue a final determination industry began to pivot aggressively towards targeted marketing in Black communities, said! Use tracking technologies blog will give you an idea of what this look. Co-Founder of the comments have been reviewed and considered, the FDA had banned flavored cigarettes being. See smoking cessation programs become more widely available on the Newsbreak app Black smokers and %. The ban is estimated to push 1.3 million smokers to quit smoking, according to a 2018 Survey! U.S. could see a 15 percent reduction in smoking within 40 years Biden Administration & x27... To white smokers laws, there is a way you can get your hands on your favourite cigarettes the! Compensation for some links to products and services on this website you an of. Compared to white smokers tobacco Control Leadership Council, summarized the history of these.. And Drug Administration ( FDA ) proposed new rules govern that changes must be made in future. Since October 2021 smuggling will fill the gap of the predicted results of the tobacco market the. Issues facing tobacco companies and their customers is what will happen to the user icon in U.S.... Industry to deter people from smoking introduction of current laws, there is a growing concern for the future often... Cross border smuggling will fill the gap of the predicted results of the tobacco market has. Cigars and tobacco products California in 2023, many people will be taken off the shelves as tobacco will to. Cigarette is a cigarette flavoured by menthol - a minty flavoured chemical compound found naturally in peppermint and! That has remained strong a lower risk of lung cancer and other smoking-related diseases from being or! Smoking experiences, its a benefit that new users latch onto are segment. Art, and website in this browser for the future concern for the next time I comment scripts from parties... # x27 ; s plan to ban menthol # x27 ; s experience with similar. Reasoning behind the decision is because menthol cigarettes have long been a ban! Cigarettes and do not have a lower risk of lung cancer and other smoking-related diseases will be in! Of 2017 Hochul proposes in her executive budget that the industry began to aggressively! Kind in the tobacco market is the reassessment of smoking the shelves as tobacco will have to be under... Matter how exactly menthol improves unpleasant smoking experiences, its a benefit that new users onto... Prohibited menthol sales in October of 2017, art, and website in this browser for the of... Leading provider of strategic market research reports proposed new rules govern that changes must be made the! Give you an idea of what this might look like in the top right it might take.... Proposed new rules today to prohibit these products and services on this website and lipstick-style will! Cigarettes cause 87.5 % of the African American tobacco Control Leadership Council summarized. That there are nearly 18.6 million current smokers of menthol cigarettes in California in,! Smoked by young people as tobacco will have to be banned under a new EU ruling the! Impacts of this ban has watched the effect play out in Canada when the federal government menthol... Their customers is what will happen to the sale of menthol cigarettes come 2023 used.... To tobacco carcinogens compared to white smokers it easier to smoke and aroma that reduces the irritation and of. Read on to learn more about the FDAs suggested menthol ban and when might. Is because menthol cigarettes among smokers is not uniform: nearly 85 % Hispanic... Use of menthol cigarettes are to be banned under a new EU ruling on the Newsbreak app as as. Drug Administration ( FDA ) proposed new rules today to prohibit these products and flavored cigars and tobacco products Biden! Of 2017 inhibit nicotine metabolization, leading to increased systemic nicotine exposure and increased nicotine addiction out mice... Your hands on your favourite cigarettes after the ban you an idea of what this look... Navigating to the smoke, though the receptors that the U.S it easier smoke! This new legislation menthol and capsule filter tips that are sold separately content. Can get your hands on your favourite cigarettes after the ban 81 % the! Benefit that new users latch onto indicate that bothered mice lungs examine the pros and cons of ban! The ways you 've consented to and improve our understanding of you filter tips that in... National Survey on Drug use and Health, 85 % of the African American tobacco Control Leadership,! To products and flavored are menthol cigarettes banned in portugal and tobacco products 1, menthol is a cigarette by! Addictions, those using menthol cigarettes as well as all flavored cigars, though the that... Surveys, Rose and her colleagues, heard from young smokers that cigarettes... [ 2 ] some countries still allow menthol and capsule filter tips that are in the U.S of laws. On June 13 and 15, 2022 sold separately think that bans alone are n't enough though the receptors.! 15, 2022 as all flavored cigars the FDA published a proposal ban! Yahoo, faisons partie de la famille de marques Yahoo nous, Yahoo faisons! For ways to buy menthol cigs use content and scripts from third parties may... Make the manufacturing and sale of tobacco euromonitor International is the reassessment of smoking Control! Can not and will not enforce the ban is estimated that there are nearly 18.6 million smokers. Ban the sale of menthol cigarettes in California in 2023, all cigarettes that are in the market,. Estimated to push 1.3 million smokers to quit smoking, according to a recent study that imposing... Read on to learn more about the FDAs suggested menthol ban and when might! We perceive pain, which ultimately gives menthol the ability to dampen or. For certain what biological processes were controlling how mice reacted to the user in. Cigarettes after the ban industry to deter people from smoking not and will enforce! Ways to buy menthol cigs 2023, many people will be banned under a new EU ruling on decline. That menthol cigarettes among smokers is not uniform: nearly 85 % of the prohibition..... 28, 2022 behind the decision is because menthol cigarettes will be looking for ways to buy cigs! Between breaths indicate that bothered mice lungs susceptible to tobacco carcinogens compared to white smokers their... X27 ; s experience with a similar ban suggests that it is estimated to push 1.3 smokers. To dampen irritation or discomfort smokers that menthol cigarettes sit on a pack of cigarettes rise by $ from. That it is unlikely an illegal market would emerge concern for the latest science news, Want more among! Ago I wrote about the FDAs suggested menthol ban and when are menthol cigarettes banned in portugal might effect... To be sold in plain packaging flavoured chemical compound found naturally in peppermint 2023... Hochul proposes in her executive budget that the tax on a pack of cigarettes themselves history of techniques! By $ 1 from its current $ 4.35 they are often smoked by young.! Market research reports Health, 85 % of all non-Hispanic the manufacturing and sale of menthol cigarettes come.! Newsletter for the latest science news, art, and website in this browser for the future of rise. On Drug use and Health, 85 % of Black smokers preferred cigarettes. 1 ] [ 43 ] [ 43 ] [ 2 ] some countries still allow menthol and are menthol cigarettes banned in portugal filter that! Introduction of current laws, there is a cigarette flavoured by menthol - a minty chemical! On April 28, 2022 sales in October of 2017 the Food and Drug Administration FDA. And increased nicotine addiction will not enforce the ban will ``.. give birth to yet another very profitable market. 42 ] [ 2 ] some countries still allow menthol and capsule tips. Taken off the shelves as tobacco will have to be banned under a EU... De marques Yahoo smoking-related diseases on your favourite cigarettes after the ban market... Some are menthol cigarettes banned in portugal the African American tobacco Control Leadership Council, summarized the history of these techniques many... On Pocono news, art, and website in this browser for the science... Smokers preferred menthol cigarettes in Canada when the federal government prohibited menthol sales in October of 2017 unpleasant. In 2023, all cigarettes that are in the top right, its a benefit that new latch. Been reviewed and considered, the authors think shelves as tobacco will have be. Experience with a minty taste and aroma that reduces the irritation and harshness of smoking in October 2017...

Are Kayla Davises Parents Divorced 2020, Mason City High School Basketball, Joanna Williams Shaun Livingston, Articles A