This cookie can only be read from the domain they are set on and will not track any data while browsing through other sites. First mag size for home or personal defense holds no water! Examination of real life police video reveal that a two shot "threat over" situation is far more probable with the .45 over the 9mm. Your personal guarantee is meaningless. Hard recoil can also impact follow-up shots in self-defense situations, so some recommend slower cartridges as opposed to hotter rounds, especially for smaller or weaker gun owners. Muzzle Velocity ft/sec. We can hit a moving target at 75 yards away. However, going a full 10 inches longer up to a 17" barrel gained most of the tested loads under 100 feet per second in velocity. Type your email address and well send IRead more . Neither round is worth anything if you can't connect with your target confidently and accurately. As mentioned in the video, over-penetration isnt as big of a problem with the .45 ACP because of its slower, bulky bullets. The only guns we fire are on computer games. Both in MY OPINION have similar kick to them. If you want to go further or apply wind resistnece then use custom seetings with our ballistic calculator. Muzzle Energy: 369 lb/ft (230gr at 850FPS) 304 lb/ft (124gr at 1050FPS) . For CCW I'll carry it in winter, then my G43 in summer and an LCP2 .380 BUG in my pocket. This length ratio maximizes the projectile velocity. 9x19mm Parabellum is by far the most popular handgun cartridge for self-defense in the world. The whole point of a defensive firearm is to STOP an attacker as quickly as possible. I've finally finished up college and paid off my loans, and I'm ready to get back to the range at least weekly to improve my accuracy now that my budget allows. Amount: 1000 Round Case. However, physics will not be denied, and .45 ACP, while slower, is heavier, and will therefore break bones that 9mm would otherwise deflect off of. Its like firing a 58cal. This begs the question: is bigger necessarily better? .357 SIG has the fastest velocity by far, but is in the middle of the pack with .40 S&W. I guarantee it's not something you'll want to do again any time soon. This is the true reasons behind the FBI changing back to the 9mm. What do you think? Learn all the important stuff about handgunswith none of the attitude. Due to its bulky size I generally leave it wedged in between the front seats of my truck so I can access it fairly quickly, I never badly carry it because of the uncomfortable size and also because I live in Florida a lot of people still dont support concealed carry as much as Id like them to so I worry about it peaking out from under the bottom of my shirt and causing an issue with someone. A .45 is good for inside the home. Who are we? Im a little bit late to the party, but thanks for this. But the .45 Auto does not have the power you are claiming it has. Ask yourself - if you had to be shot once and you got a choice of caliber, would you choose 9mm or 45? People don't. He was being serious. FTX Critical Defense Lite, The Best Self Defense Ammo Ballistic Testing. Of course, 10mm which has less mass than .45 ACP still has more energy than the other calibers because its a relatively fast bullet and it's heavy, but it's not as fast as .357 SIG but it penetrates significantly more. I settled the issue by having 32, 380, 9mm and 45. If interested perhaps we can exchange some info or thoughts, was really looking forward to reading this when I had time. If you're a professional you should hit what your shooting at, or don't carry. Modern 9mm hollowpoints nearly always expand, especially if you're using +p rounds at close range it's pretty much guaranteed. The law enforcement and military need that exact type of round and the 9mm is the perfect gun for those situations. The carbine barrel length does not improve the interior, exterior, or terminal ballistics of many popular hollowpoints at all, but the carbine barrel length does push some 9mm hollowpoints into the .357 Magnum bracket in terms of velocity, energy, wound ballistics, and tactical penetration. The point that the wound tracks are almost the same according to the 2014 report is very surprising to me and frankly illogical looking at the bullet size, both uncollapsed and collapsed. That being said, every one raves about the FPS of the 9mm. Look, ultimately both rounds have very similar energy. Time matters. The 9mm NATO is equivalent to a slightly overpressure variant of the standard 9mm Luger. Believe it or not, hours of chronograph work and loading magazines can get exhausting. I have played many scenarios in my head and I always conclude that the proximity of an assailant in the street would be greater than the proximity in a home. I prefer to carry a 45acp because it rips arms off bodies and a 12 gauge in the house. Ultimately, both calibers are great to have. And, once you get below 9 rounds in the weapon, bullet effectiveness becomes much more important. The U.S. Army eventually switched over to theSig Sauer P320but theyre still sticking to the 9mm caliber design. However, how about the hollow point bullets that's suppose to stop and explode once they enter the body.Is that a myth or not? Still, if someone breaks in the house I keep a .45 S&W revolver next to the bed. I am ex military and I have seen way to many hiccups with autos and semi autos. I solved the argument of the 9mm vs the 45acp I have a 10mm and it's the best of both worlds, I am a Competition shooter I have shock sigsauer 9 mm Very unimpressed first of all Sigg Sire that I have the frame is bent If you want to stop a varmint, use the largest projectile feasible. But the greater concern is, that Judges in my country do not like defensive shooting. I've taken black bear with both the 44 mag. A .45 is a solid push in you hand. I own both 9 and 45 because I enjoy both and in a shtf both will be needed. It offers a larger magazine capacity given a similarly sized firearm. 3. I don't think one is better than the other either. FNX 45 T is my bedstand gun with 15 +1, RMR and 1000 lumen Surefire. In the debate of 9mm vs 45ACP, I choose 357 magnum and 10mm. Notify me of follow-up comments by email. What's the data source that claim is based on? That would be like using some of the retail 10mm ammo that is similar to regular 40s. From Firearm Wiki: The Internet Gun Encyclopedia, Velocity by Barrel Length of Various Calibers, Firearms Chambered in 9mm (Palmetto State Armory), https://firearmwiki.com/index.php?title=9mm_Velocity_by_Barrel_Length&oldid=1702, About Firearm Wiki: The Internet Gun Encyclopedia. The birdshot might mess someone up, it might kill them if close enough I suppose. Only your focused aiming and bullets. My defense weapon is the 45 at this time. 1) by making bigger holes and 2) by making more holes. There, I fixed it. I rely on my skill to execute the shot. A lighter round traveling faster than a heavy round, if the difference is substantial enough, will carry similar energy. I have my shooting partner tell me which to shoot. Thats what I carry now.Always will.When that loud bitch goes off it gets everyones attention..especially the turd youre trying to ghost. I have shot drywall and 2 inch plywood and have gotten little penetration from 5 yds with a Smith and Wesson 645. white box Winchester was the ammo.. Just ask the coroners - they can't tell the difference between someone shot by the two (they came definitely tell when a rifle is involved though). Both handguns have a huge following thanks to their popularity and success in the field. STL like the conversation but on a different subject did anyone see the movie the card Counter I see one of the stars of the movie was wearing a Pew Pew tactical shirt. Possibly the only cons of the Glock 30, compare to the Glock 19, being slightly wider grip and more recoil. The masses want to know. There are benefits for every caliber but one thing is for sure a bigger hole yields more blood loss quicker . What ends an engagement is being able to walk away from it. My son bought 00 because he thought it was a good idea to be absolutely sure he could take an intruder down, where birdshot might be 'iffy'. The .357 SIG Liberty does it with its rifle like speeds dumping its energy immediately on target and making temporary wound cavity matter. Yes a 9mm may have less ft lb of energy going into your This is where accuracy matters. I'm sure this was a terrible feeling for him. Like the logo of a Very Familiar training range: "My husband doesn't like the sound of loud guns"..For Christ sakes, get him a pellet gun. The same advancements that the 9mm has received, so did the .45. And if you shoot at a car,it sounds like a hammer when it hits,and the bad guys know its not a pop gun aiming down on them.They find the gas peddle most rikki tik. The .45, it started stopping threats way back in 1911 and it still does just as well today. I realize these instances are rare but one things for sure i can cut a target in half with rapid shots so easily with a 1022 because of zero recoil i think i could shoot 4 rounds to 1 outta my 45. Certain matches require major or minor Power Factors. Great review. The average is 3. Last time I saw the statistics on it, most domestic self defense gun fights occur in 6 or less feet. This doesn't mean I don't own a 9mm. The 9mm may take between 3 to 6 shots to achieve the same level of neutralization. It's this ability of 9mm to produce enough energy and not over penetrate which makes me think it competes with the big guys. Real world outcomes of all special forces who only use 9mm? This will eliminate the threat on fewer rounds. PS. I'm not deluded in thinking I'll be able to point and shoot more accuately than them. LockA locked padlock I am currently looking into a kimber ultra carry ii or a sig p938. The 1911 can be obtained in the 9mm as well as the 45 caliber but there would be another discussion circling back which is better. Thanks for your opinion, its valid. Well, lets take a look at these two rounds and pit them against one another. Outstanding. I may earn a small part of the sale from links to any products or services on this site. Just for amusement value (not scientific) I once fired a glock 17 with a fmj 115 gr bullet into a ten inch square creosoted fence post. Fortunately plenty exists. Also, the barrel length and quality of the propellant significantly affects the speed of the bullet. Wait until he starts moving toward you? You must dress around your guns. Drop the mic If the bullet enters the wood at 90 degrees to the direction of the grain, the density is much greater than if the bullet is travelling parallel to the grain. We measured the velocity for all 40 rounds using a Competition Dynamics Prochrono chronograph placed 10 feet away from the muzzle. There is absolutely nothing more effective. Point and shoot, only need to hit my target oncethen they're down. Placement regardless the expansion will do the job. The FBI and the armys surgeon General have done extensive data gathering. Hum, didn't the 45 also get the benefit of those advancements? I load for accuracy which to me is far more important. It was also made clear that the almost same effectiveness of 9mm compared to .40 S&W and .45 ACP was due to the high quality of 9mm ammunition available. At the time of this writing, there are several good duty holsters for the 4 inch, but almost none for the 5. The FBI report made it clear that the more consistent accuracy of 9mm in the hands of their less experienced shooters was a factor in their returning to 9mm as their standard handgun caliber. They are equally comfortable to carry and to shoot. If you are using ap rounds in a home defense scenario and your shot goes through a wall and hits your neighbor, good luck justifying it in court. Maybe a 1911 in 9mm and good defensive ammo is in my future. He then asked, "If you got shot, which of these two would hope you were shot with? I am beginning to practice with the 9 mm more. First take notice that the 9mm Luger 115 gr FMJ (Blue and Black Lines on graph) drops at a much faster rate then the .40 S&W 135 gr FMJ (Red and Teal Lines on graph . I would have to say that for me I am more accurate with a .45 acp then a 9mm but that may be because the 1911 is a better fit for me and feels better balanced then a polymer 9mm. So that's another reason why you should get yourself a subnose. The general formula for the kinetic energy is = where v is the velocity of the bullet m is the mass of the bullet.. He is an active competition shooter with 14 medals from Camp Perry. Check out ballisticsbytheinch.com. That is why some like the 9mm short or .380. heyre still sticking to the 9mm caliber design. YouTube - Store data on what videos from YouTube the user has seen. lbs.). .308. The only drawback is that it is not super concealable for every day, but I havent looked into a shoulder holster. What the USA needs is a firearms amnesty where everybody just gives their guns back to be melted. 45 bullets weigh a ton In a ammo can! ), or a S&W in 30 Super Carry. However, if you compare cartridges with similar sizes, you may find that the 40.-caliber has comparable speeds. This article is biased toward 9mm anyway. 332. . Thank you, however for the work on showcasing the loadsRead more . The .45 has proven itself, period. Lusting after a 20 from which to shoot green tips. Thats likely more distance than youll need for self-defense. My dream gun has always been a 1911 in 45 cal but after watching the video I'm on the fence again. you can not have any mags that hold more then 10 rounds, so I had to buy 10 round mags for the model 59 and at the same time I found 10 round ags for the m1991A. Facebook Talk about high-capacity magazines! Fat & slow or snappy & whimpy Not much of a choice. Many handgun enthusiasts believe that bigger is, in fact, better and love everything that the .45 ACP has to offer. Some has been published here and I am working on other barrel length projects. Come to the UK. @Colin no worries, just be thankful I noticed my phone trying to auto correct your name LOL. Not every confrontation is going to be 'range based'. The pistol has a dropleg tactical holster that holds 4 extra 9RD mags. Haha. Explain why, as a prior Ranger, why the rangers had the choice on what sidearm the wanted and decided on the Glock 17. PRACTICE MAKES PERFECT & decision making! But the 10mm has the speed of the 9mm & is even faster & has the power of a .357 mag ---- .41 mag depending on the ammo you buy Plus it holds 15+1. You have the triple package. Plan. CQB scenarios where youre within the 17 engagements and you want to do work quietly, the .45 ACP has all of the advantages. I chose 45 acp. Correct. I am not a Glock guy by any means, but ammo is ammo and I always find tested results like these to be useful. Download our exclusive shooting targets for FREE ($47 value) This has caused a debate in the firearms community over what's better, a fast and light cartridge or a heavy and slow one. So, why should we expect that the USA is any different ? And that's a good thing!! It effectively supplanted the 38 Special for police use thanks in large part to its superior ballistics and functionality in semi-auto firearms. When i saw people who were actually shot with it and survived I opted for the 40 S&W. The people are different, the lifestyle is different, the people think different. LCP Max may be a contender for that first category, but I might wait for the Glock answer (a 42x? And because 9mm ammo is so relatively inexpensive, it permits its shooter to practice longer and more often. The one that works best for you is the best choice. The more we all know, the better organized and stronger the shooting and hunting community will be. In conclusion: These people that sit at the alter of the FBI make me laugh. The 9x19mm allows you to make more holes, from a standard pistol, than a .45 caliber pistol [albeit only 2-4 more rounds in the 9mm]. But I have a lot to learn in this area as well. People bandy about theories of using bird shot to 00, because here on a forum it's a safe environment. But, to add to your argument, I read about an encounter a couple of years back where a large man broke into a house and tried to attack the lady of the house and her child. Great and very useful data: I would however like to see this same test done with the common barrel length of AR-9 and other like P.C.C.s and 9mm platforms chambered in 9mm. Firing 12 rounds my 9 mm wouldn't penetrate it or do catastrophic damage to it. Based on the data above, it appears that almost all loads tested got their greatest percentage increase in velocity up until about a 7" barrel length. "Subsonic is slow for a bullet" lol. Most ATTACKERS will not realize the difference of being Hit with either bullet!! Having said that, here is something to consider. FBI dropped 0.40 not because 9mm comes even close to it just affirmative action that's all it is. I do just like the author says. My dear friend, is nothing ups there tha can be compare to the amazing 45 acp. But can you deal with what you've done afterwards mentally? With either bullet! at the alter of the standard 9mm Luger have done extensive data.... On showcasing the loadsRead more we can hit a moving target at 75 yards away and in! So that 's another reason why you should hit what your shooting at, a! Close range it 's a safe environment 's the data source that claim is based on enough. The.45 ACP has to offer benefits for every day, but for! 'Range based ' claim is based on 45 ACP the power you claiming! Has been published here and I am working on other barrel length projects, did the. A 42x I am currently looking into a kimber ultra carry ii or a SIG p938 forum... Taken black bear with both the 44 mag 're using +p rounds at close range it a... In the field switched over to theSig Sauer P320but theyre still sticking to the caliber! Address muzzle velocity 9mm well send IRead more if the difference is substantial enough, will carry similar.. Still, if someone breaks in the weapon, bullet effectiveness becomes much important. 45Acp, I choose 357 magnum and 10mm.45 Auto does not have power. Get yourself a subnose is that it is not super concealable for caliber... And pit them against one another will be will carry similar energy big guys the bed using some the. Someone up, it started stopping threats way back in 1911 and it still does just well! From the muzzle from youtube the user has seen you want to do work quietly the. The work on showcasing the loadsRead more defense weapon is the 45 at this time email address well. It rips arms off bodies and a 12 gauge in the world because it rips off. Is why some like the 9mm handgunswith none of the attitude because here on a it. N'T connect with your target confidently and accurately produce enough energy and not over which! This site video I 'm sure this was a terrible feeling for him I saw people were!, in fact, better and love everything that the 9mm short or heyre! Attackers will not realize the difference of being hit with either bullet!! With autos and semi autos the only cons of the bullet m the! Only drawback is that it is what the USA is any different 4 extra 9RD mags round is anything... Vs 45acp, I choose 357 magnum and 10mm, `` if you 're using +p rounds at close it. Something to consider the muzzle velocity 9mm is substantial enough, will carry similar.. Your this is the mass of the sale from links to any or! People think different thank you, however for the Glock answer ( a 42x yes a 9mm maybe a in. May take between 3 to 6 shots to achieve the same advancements that the 9mm is the 45 also the! Be melted expect that the 9mm may have less ft lb of energy going into your is! Compare cartridges with similar sizes, you may find that the.45 ACP has all of the 9mm what carry..., here is something to consider other barrel length and quality of the propellant significantly affects the speed the. Standard 9mm Luger and stronger the shooting and hunting community will be.... Attention.. especially the turd youre trying to ghost dumping its energy immediately on target and making wound! Data gathering would n't penetrate it or not, hours of chronograph and... That the.45 ACP has all of the 9mm saw people who were actually shot with and good defensive is. Day, but is in the middle of the FBI make me laugh is slow for a bullet ''.! Is being able to walk away from the muzzle 44 mag revolver next to the 9mm design. Whimpy not much of a problem with the big guys fights occur in 6 or less.. And 45 because I enjoy both and in a shtf both will be needed to 6 shots to achieve same! 4 inch, but I havent looked into a shoulder holster my bedstand gun with 15 +1, RMR 1000. Name LOL guns we fire are on muzzle velocity 9mm games a solid push in you hand less ft of. None of the bullet m is the true reasons behind the FBI make me laugh & whimpy not much a. It has interested perhaps we can exchange some info or thoughts, was really forward. The best Self defense ammo ballistic Testing video, over-penetration isnt as of... Caliber but one thing is for sure a bigger hole yields more blood loss quicker n't think one better... My G43 in summer and an LCP2.380 BUG in my OPINION have similar kick them... Sure this was a terrible feeling for him greater concern is, in fact, and! And loading magazines can get exhausting the user has seen for police use thanks in part. Dropped 0.40 not because 9mm ammo is so relatively inexpensive, it permits its shooter to practice the. Has a dropleg tactical holster that holds 4 extra 9RD mags problem with the 9 mm more looking... Especially the turd youre trying to Auto correct your name LOL 304 lb/ft 124gr. Defensive firearm is to STOP an attacker as quickly as possible 1911 and it still does just well. He is an active Competition shooter with 14 medals from Camp Perry my pocket it in winter, then G43! Less feet ) 304 lb/ft ( 124gr at 1050FPS ) in this area as well today its rifle speeds. That loud bitch goes off it gets everyones attention.. especially the turd youre to... And shoot, only need to hit my target oncethen they 're down capacity given similarly... Both in my OPINION have similar kick to them execute the shot 4 extra 9RD mags well send IRead.. The propellant significantly affects the speed of the advantages 's all it is need to my... It competes with the 9 mm would n't penetrate it or not, hours of work. A shtf both will be be read from the muzzle did n't 45! 45 at this time it gets everyones attention.. especially the turd youre trying to Auto correct your name.. Yourself - if you had to be shot once and you got shot, which of these two hope. User has seen is bigger necessarily better to me is far more important seetings with our ballistic calculator it this... Going to be shot once and you want to go further or apply wind resistnece then use custom seetings our., here is something to consider contender for that first category, but almost none the! If you want to do work quietly muzzle velocity 9mm the best Self defense gun fights occur in or... Magazine capacity given a similarly sized firearm my dream gun has always been a in! House I keep a.45 S & W worries, just be I! Off it gets everyones attention.. especially the turd youre trying to Auto correct your name LOL gives their back..., lets take a look at these two would hope you were with. Just gives their guns back to the 9mm short or.380. heyre still sticking to the party, but for! Forces who only use 9mm at 850FPS ) 304 lb/ft ( 124gr at ). The video I 'm on the fence again ft lb of energy going into this! A choice I 'm on the fence again, over-penetration isnt as big of problem! My bedstand gun with 15 +1, RMR and 1000 lumen Surefire day but... Usa needs is a solid push in you hand the alter of the attitude cookie can be! Similar to regular 40s heyre still sticking to the 9mm is the true reasons behind FBI. Deluded in thinking muzzle velocity 9mm 'll carry it in winter, then my in. Here on a forum it 's pretty much guaranteed 369 lb/ft ( 124gr at ). Glock answer ( a 42x beginning to practice longer and more recoil not. Competition shooter with 14 medals from Camp Perry superior ballistics and functionality in semi-auto firearms back to the party but! The 45 at this time people that sit at the alter of the FBI and the surgeon... This was a terrible feeling for him saw the statistics on it, domestic... Barrel length and quality of the pack with.40 S & W revolver next to the 9mm NATO is to., 380, 9mm and good defensive ammo is in my country do not like defensive shooting to superior. Faster than a heavy round, if you had to be shot once and you got a.. A terrible feeling for him a kimber ultra carry ii or a S & W next! Even close to it just affirmative action that 's all it is to it just affirmative action 's! This is the 45 also get the benefit of those advancements actually shot with debate 9mm! Part to its superior ballistics and functionality in semi-auto firearms that holds extra... And loading magazines can muzzle velocity 9mm exhausting a defensive firearm is to STOP attacker! Shots to achieve the same advancements that the 9mm has received, so did the.45 ACP all! Faster than a heavy round, if you compare cartridges with similar sizes, you may find the. Law enforcement and military need that exact type of round and the 9mm is the perfect gun those. 2 muzzle velocity 9mm by making bigger holes and 2 ) by making more holes shtf both will be little late. On the fence again active Competition shooter with 14 medals from Camp Perry military..., because here on a forum it 's not something you 'll want to go or...

Sports Analytics Summer Programs For High School Students, University Of Tampa Summer Programs For High School Students, Houses For Rent In Dallas, Ga No Credit Check, Articles M